I wholeheartedly agree with everything just stated by Gary OldMan. We are all aware he was a fan of the Up series but you shouldn't just automatically add any new additions to HIS list.
With inflated self importance and extremely finite wisdom, the keepers of lists decided they could speak for the late Mr. Ebert and add the 2019 '63 Up' to his list.
This is wildly inappropriate, sacrilegious and arrogant. I don't understand how they could have thought this either necessary or a good idea.
Add your comment
Comments 1 - 15 of 49
Gary OldMan
Ebert died in 2013. Did someone contact him via seance to add a new film to his list in 2019?Timec
Thanks, Mr. Ebert. I'll see you at the movies.Gary OldMan
@mi-16evilEbert reviewed 49 and 56 before his death. That's the difference.
List mania has run amok when random people start deciding what is "pretty clear" a dead man would add to his list.
I'll repeat: Why was this either necessary or a good idea?
TimA1030
I wholeheartedly agree with everything just stated by Gary OldMan. We are all aware he was a fan of the Up series but you shouldn't just automatically add any new additions to HIS list.Gary OldMan
With inflated self importance and extremely finite wisdom, the keepers of lists decided they could speak for the late Mr. Ebert and add the 2019 '63 Up' to his list.This is wildly inappropriate, sacrilegious and arrogant. I don't understand how they could have thought this either necessary or a good idea.
Ebert's list should remain HIS list.
gama_jr
Why this list is changing?ViniciusOG
Another Ebert's list. Hope you like it!http://www.icheckmovies.com/lists/roger+eberts+i+hated+hated+hated+this+movie/vinigodoy/
Ralf
11 Funniest Lines from Roger Ebert's Reviews of Bad MoviesAlfredo Garcia
So long, Mr. Ebert.Thorkell
Very sad. I guess that means the end of updates for this list. :(Mochard
@Anonym They are not ranked, they are in the order Ebert wrote the reviews.Paper_Okami
Questionable? You do realize that people have different tastes in movies don't you?Giorz
Good bye, Mr. Ebert, thanks for this list, for your work and the knowledge you shared with us.Knaldskalle
Resquiescat in Pace.Lord X
Farewell, Good Sir.Showing items 1 – 15 of 49