On Dangerous Ground (1951)

Top comments

1. 

   dombrewer

   Several things raise this noir out of the ordinary and into the under-rated classic status - Nicholas Ray's clever direction; the beautiful B&W photography of shadow covered city and snow covered countryside; Bernard Herrmann's typically wonderful score and the lead performance of Robert Ryan as city detective Jim Wilson - stonily impassive and impressively grim. Driven by the loneliness of his life and the pressures of his job to a dangerous, sadistic loathing of the criminals he is dealing with, Wilson is sent out of the city for his own good to help investigate the murder of a local girl. His redemption comes in the shape of a blind woman called Mary (Ida Lupino), who knows more about the murder than she initially lets on. It's a shame that Ray didn't manage to stick with the originally planned ending -

   Mary refuses Jim and he returns to the city alone but improved by his experiences and able to continue. As it stands the sentimental ending feels strange after all the sleaze of the city and the melancholy that's come before it,

   but all the same it's a strong film; excellently made and well worth a watch. 11 years 3 months ago
2. 

   flaiky

   Starts brilliantly, but goes downhill and feels a bit silly once Ida Lupino appears...the snowy setting is great though. 8 years 8 months ago
3. 

   few visible scars

   Regrettably I feel I have to agree with flaiky .. The idea that a film "goes downhill and feels a bit silly once Ida Lupino appears" should just not be possible.. but her character as an overly angelic 'sweet little blind girl' feels like it's from a 1918 Griffiths film played by lillian Gish and it all goes soggy. I see another person here - dombrewer- tells us there should have been another ending .. I'm off to find out what that was, and if it would have saved this otherwise promising film from the syrup... 8 years ago

Friends